Chapter 1712

Chapter 1712 "Would you like some wine?" "Yes." The red wine had been stored here. Charlie took a bottle, opened it, and poured two glasses of red wine. In the light, the red wine was swaying inside the glasses. It had a beautiful and elegant luster. The atmosphere was romantic. Charlie took out a bunch of red roses and handed it to Grace. Grace blinked as she gazed at the roses. "When did you prepare these?" "After you agreed to move in here." Charlie was still on one knee, holding the bright red roses. She didn't take the flowers, leaned against the floor-to-ceiling window behind her, and said with curiosity, "What made you realize you were wrong?" "Summer came over and scolded me. She told me what you had suffered. She sharply pointed out my mistakes and made me feel ashamed." Grace's expression changed slightly. She stared at him. "I thought you realized that yourself. If not for Summer, you might have never reflected on what you had done." Waves of disappointment washed