Chapter 165

Billy's words immediately grabbed Esther's attention. She reluctantly opened the car door and settled into the back seat, avoiding any conversation with him. Glancing at Esther through the rearview mirror, Billy couldn't help but notice how different she looked from her mother, Faye. Perhaps it was because Esther resembled her biological father more. Over the years, Billy believed he had fulfilled his role, neither treating Esther exceptionally well nor poorly. However, when conflicts arose between Esther and Liliane, Billy prioritized Liliane's protection. Given a choice between his biological daughter and his adopted daughter with no blood ties, Billy selfishly leaned toward his own flesh and blood. He didn't think he deserved blame for that; he was no saint, just an ordinary man and father. His true affections naturally belonged to Liliane, his biological daughter, a sentiment common to many. Esther remained silent in the back seat of the BMW, avoiding any conversation with Billy