Chapter 565

Toby had thought Melina only knew a bit about it. He had never expected Andrew to tell her the whole story. Other than those who had witnessed it back then, only Toby knew about these events. Even Elliot and the others were completely unaware. A trace of surprise crossed Toby's eyes, and his tone grew more somber. "If you know, then you must understand. Everything Andrew did was for a reason. I'm not trying to excuse him, but don't you think he's pitiful?" Melina nodded. "Yes, he's pitiful. If it had been me, I might not have survived those tormenting years." Toby breathed a sigh of relief. "So then... are you willing to give Andrew another chance?" He felt anyone who knew Andrew's history would feel compassion. If Melina knew, maybe she would forgive him and be willing to start over. However, Melina shook her head. "No, I'm not willing." Toby was stunned. "Why? Andrew knows he was wrong. He genuinely cares about you." "I understand his past is pitiful, but I can't let pity be