Chapter 1759

Phoebe held her hand up, keeping the ring in plain sight. She continued, "Tyler personally put this ring on me. We chose it together." Olivia scoffed, glancing away from the ring. She began to walk past Phoebe. Phoebe quickly stepped in front of her again, surprised by Olivia's calm reaction. She didn't expect Olivia to just walk away like that. "What do you really want?" Olivia looked sideways at her, her patience thinning. She lifted her face and raised her eyebrows. "Can't you see what's in my hand?" Olivia replied, "Of course I can see it. But Ms. Phoebe, are you sure you both picked this ring out together?" Phoebe faltered for a moment, looking confused. Olivia then said, "This ring was my old wedding ring." Phoebe's face changed immediately, her eyes widening in shock. Olivia watched her closely and asked, "Did you not know where this ring came from, or did Tyler not explain its history when he gave it to you?" Phoebe's expression showed her panic mixed with embarrassmen